Silver Emulsion

Film Reviews

Close Encounters of the Third Kind (1977)

Close Encounters of the Third Kind (1977)

Starring Richard Dreyfuss, François Truffaut, Teri Garr, Melinda Dillon, Bob Balaban, J. Patrick McNamara, Warren J. Kemmerling, Roberts Blossom, Philip Dodds, Cary Guffey

Directed by Steven Spielberg

Expectations: Love it. Haven’t seen it in a while.


Steven Spielberg’s Close Encounters of the Third Kind is a masterful film, bursting at the seams with a wealth of beautifully composed shots, wonderful John Williams music and a great sense of wonder. This is the kind of film only a budding filmmaker could have made, a true love letter to the dreamer fueled on passion and heart. This is made all the more interesting by the fact that in this case, the dream itself is implanted into our hero’s mind by the extraterrestrials. Much in the same way, Spielberg has inserted his own vision of first contact into millions of minds, forever changing the way we look at aliens.

Special Edition Re-Release Poster

Roy Neary (Richard Dreyfuss) is an everyday man with an electric company job. He gets a call one night as the power goes down around the city. In his truck on his way to investigate, a mysterious light singles out his truck and quickly flies off before Roy can figure out exactly what he’s just seen. He hears a report of a sighting on the squawk box and heads in the direction, only to find a small group of people already waiting there. Their watchful eyes give away that they are not here by chance. Some small ships with bright-colored lights turn the corner and fly overhead. If Roy was hallucinating before, there is no question now. He just saw a UFO.

Close Encounters has the distinction of being the only film where Spielberg is credited as writer/director. Not being a writer by trade, a number of uncredited writers helped him out at various stages of the game, but regardless, this is his story. This is the one that kept him up at nights, wondering and theorizing. This one is special in his heart and that passion is evident throughout the finished film. The story first came about as a student film named Firelight, made in 1964 for $500. I’m unclear just how close the two films are in terms of story, but the basic premise is shared. In any case, the thought of first contact had been on Spielberg’s mind for years leading up to making Close Encounters, so I’m sure just making the film fulfilled a big dream of his.

For Close Encounters to work effectively on you, you need to approach the film with a general wonder about the universe already installed. I’m sure there are people out there that will have their sense of wonder awoken by the film, but to truly connect with the story and participate in the journey, you should have given some thought to the existence of life outside of Earth before watching the film. This way when Roy becomes implanted with the visions of Devil’s Tower and he is compelled to go there, he is also transformed into a stand-in for your own hopes and dreams. This may not have been his lifelong goal, but he was selected and can do nothing to fight the urge. The astronauts in the final scene, people who have prepared for this occasion specifically and dreamed about it their whole lives, are denied that final realization that Roy achieves. The viewers themselves are denied it as well, as despite our dreams they do not qualify us to go inside. Roy becomes a surrogate for all of us, a chosen example of humanity. What makes him special is never explained, and that’s just fine, as the ambiguity of the final scenes are perfect. Obviously if you’re watching the Special Edition, you do get to see inside the ship, but I would argue that this only diminishes the film and the power of its mystery.

Vilmos Zsigmond’s Oscar-winning cinematography is absolutely astounding, perfectly capturing every aspect of the production. Douglas Trumball’s work on the colored lights of the alien ships is without equal in the history of cinema and are especially wondrous. The film hinges on these FX grabbing you and being ultimately believable and they still achieve that to this day. The film compositing work on this movie is also amazing, once again proving that the pain-staking work of old can still rival the hours of work by multiple computer technicians. Seriously, this is one of the most technically sound special effects movies of all time, with near seamless integration into the finished frames of film. It’s truly mind-blowing how well-done it all is, and I can only imagine the mind-blast that was this and Star Wars coming out in the same year. They brought out all the stops in 1977.

The film is also superbly edited and has a slow, building pace that culminates in one of the greatest and most triumphant science fiction endings of all-time. As far as I know, Spielberg’s approach to aliens hadn’t been done in film prior to this, that is, a non-violent first contact. It plays out in quite the realistic way, with communication via technology and music. I’ve always loved the addition of basic musical tones here, as music is one of the most basic and primal aspects of our psyche, and it makes some sense that we might be able to communicate at some level with it. To be honest though, we never know exactly what we’re saying with the tones and for all I know Roy was thrown into a traditional Venusian BBQ pit with a Martian apple in his mouth just after the mothership’s hatch closed.

Anyway, editing! The film is one interesting beast to any student of film editing and the most recent DVD/Blu-ray release allows for some deep consideration of the various versions Close Encounters has been in over the years. Three different cuts are included, 1977 Theatrical, 1980 Special Edition, & 1998 Definitive Director’s Cut. I watched the 1998 cut this time around, and have the last couple of viewings. It’s a really well put together version of the film, combining elements from both previous cuts.

Close Encounters of the Third Kind is one of the greatest science fiction movies of all time. After the wild success of Jaws, Spielberg was given incredible freedom to make this film how he liked, and boy did he hit it out of the park. While my mind might have strayed a bit here and there throughout this viewing, I attribute that more to my familiarity with the film, having seen it several times. I always think back to my first viewing of it though, where I was in absolute rapture over it. It’s such a wonderful journey that chooses not to follow a traditional film structure, much like how Roy’s journey to Devil’s Tower is anything but orthodox. An amazing film that holds up incredibly well over thirty years later. Can’t say that for a lot of special effects heavy films.

November 13, 2010 - Posted by | 1970s, Drama, Movie Reviews, Rating: 4 Stars, Science Fiction | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,


  1. I had no idea that François Truffaut acted in this!

    Loved this when I was a kid…

    Comment by Joachim Boaz | November 13, 2010 | Reply

    • Wow, that was a lightning fast comment. Truffaut is great in this! He was always my favorite character for some reason.

      Comment by Will Silver | November 13, 2010 | Reply

  2. Coincidence — haha…

    Yeah, I just didn’t know he was much of an actor. I do enjoy some of his movies — Day for Night, etc.

    Comment by Joachim Boaz | November 13, 2010 | Reply

    • He’s not really, this is the only movie he was in that he didn’t direct and I think most of those parts are small cameos, but I haven’t seen a lot of them. I love 400 Blows and Small Change. Haven’t seen Day for Night. He’s one of those guys I’m very intrigued by as a director but I have yet to really dive in. One of these days…

      Comment by Will Silver | November 14, 2010 | Reply

  3. This really IS a truly great movie, and you have honoured it with an inspired and beauitfully written review

    Comment by dangerousmeredith | November 13, 2010 | Reply

    • Thanks so much! Definitely one of Spielberg’s best films.

      Comment by Will Silver | November 14, 2010 | Reply

  4. Excellent review and I really appreciate your analysis of the film’s editing, it’s something I didn’t discuss in my own review of the film. But you’re spot on – it’s worthy of being shown to students as the way to do it.

    As you know, it’s my favourite Spielberg film. I think it’s the moment everything that made Spielberg the filmmaker he is/was came out in the film. It was personal and it was authentic. He’s made some good films since but they aren’t as personal and honest as this. E.T. and Close Encounters were the two films that cut to Spielberg’s core – sandwich Jaws in between and you have his three best works.

    Comment by Dan | November 15, 2010 | Reply

    • Thanks, Dan! I agree that ET and Close Encounters are largely personal and are great pieces of Spielberg at the top of his game. He’s one of the few that can walk the line between commercial and artistic and do both well.

      Comment by Will Silver | November 15, 2010 | Reply

  5. I wish Spielberg would do more personal stories like this.

    Comment by Fitz | November 15, 2010 | Reply

    • Yes, he really has gotten away from that kind of stuff in the last few years. One of the saddest stories I heard was from an interview promoting his awful War of the Worlds movie, where he basically says that he had to put aside everything he personally believed about extraterrestrial life in order to make the movie because Tom Cruise asked him to do it. So frustrating! You’re Spielberg, do what you want!

      Comment by Will Silver | November 15, 2010 | Reply

  6. Great review Will! I agree on every point. I think the only thing I’d add is a comment about three-year-old Cary Guffey, who was amazingly “real” as little Barry. It showed how well Spielberg could work with child actors (a prelude to E.T. and Empire of the Sun). I agree 1000% with the special effects comments. Even though I realize it won’t happen, I’d love a filmmaker to attempt to make a sci-fi movie using the “old-fashioned” tricks again.

    On a related note, have you seen the teaser trailer for “Super 8”? Visually, it reminder me of “Close Encounters…”, although it takes a much darker turn for sure!

    Comment by Joel G. Robertson | November 16, 2010 | Reply

    • Thanks, Joel. I would also love to see someone do it right and bust out the models for a good sci-fi film. Did you see Inception? That made great use of physical FX and old school compositing.

      I just saw the Super 8 trailer. It does have a similar visual look to Close Encounters, but I was frustrated with the CG. I had thought it was going to be a low-budget CG-free movie, but I guess I was wrong.

      Comment by Will Silver | November 16, 2010 | Reply

  7. I think the key to this film, is like you said, already having that built in sense of wonder. Without that, the film would just be tedious and dull. It’s a fantastic film, one of Spielberg’s best and a one of a kind film.

    Comment by James Blake Ewing | November 19, 2010 | Reply

    • One of a kind is a good way to put it. I’ve never seen anything quite like it.

      I’ve known a few people that hated this movie and they were the type of person that were never inclined to think about aliens or first contact or anything, and thus they thought it was boring and stupid. They aren’t wrong, Close Encounters is just a movie that knows its audience and plays directly to it without bothering about catering to bringing in others. Similar in a way to how the imprinted are single-minded and stop at nothing to get to Devil’s Tower.

      Comment by Will Silver | November 20, 2010 | Reply

  8. Have any of you Spielberg nerds seen this?

    AMAZING the translation of his talent. The classic Spielberg kineticism along with his particular take of “extra-terrestrials” is all there. I believe that the concept is very original.

    Comment by Mike_D | November 20, 2010 | Reply

    • HAHAHA, yeah I watched that. It looks good, why did they cancel? Spielberg could fund it on his pocket change. What was the gameplay to be like, do you know?

      Comment by Will Silver | November 21, 2010 | Reply

      • Yes, I do! It was described in the article.

        See. You the player are following this AI (miss ET). As an alien, her actions are unpredictable, but never the less you must guide the adventure as she runs almost independent of yourself whilst also surviving outside hostiles. It seems so perfect.

        Comment by Mike_D | November 21, 2010 | Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: